Head/Hands of Girl Missing for Two Decades Discovered In Freezer

The had and hands of a 16-year-old girl who has been missing for nearly two decades were just discovered in a freezer in Colorado.

It’s hard to know if this is good news or bad news. Sure, there’s some closure for the family, but what gut-punching news…

At a glance:

  • The remains of 16-year-old Amanda Leariel Overstreet, missing since 2005, were discovered in a freezer in a newly sold home in Grand Junction, Colorado.
  • Overstreet’s head and hands were found when the new owner offered a free appliance, leading to the chilling discovery.
  • Authorities have no record of Overstreet ever being reported missing, and the investigation into her disappearance and death is ongoing.

The discovery of human remains in a freezer at a newly sold home in Grand Junction, Colorado, has reopened a cold case that has remained unsolved for nearly two decades. The remains were identified as those of Amanda Leariel Overstreet, who was just 16 years old when she disappeared in 2005.

On January 12, 2024, the Mesa County Sheriff’s Office responded to a call regarding a suspicious incident at the Pinyon Avenue residence. The new owner of the home, after offering a free appliance to a visitor, was horrified when the recipient found human remains inside the freezer. Law enforcement was immediately called to the scene, where they discovered the head and hands of a human being. This set off a months-long investigation into the shocking find.

Through DNA testing, the victim was identified as Amanda Leariel Overstreet, the biological daughter of the home’s previous owner. Overstreet, who had not been seen or heard from since April 2005, was never reported missing, which adds another layer of mystery to this tragic case. The authorities believe she was 16 at the time of her death.

Overstreet’s body parts were discovered after the home had been fully remodeled and sold to a new owner. The current residents have no connection to the case, and police have urged the public to respect their privacy.

Despite the breakthrough in identifying the remains, significant questions remain unanswered, including how and why Overstreet’s remains ended up in the freezer. Police are continuing their investigation, and forensic experts are analyzing evidence to piece together the events that led to her tragic death. The investigation is ongoing, and the Mesa County Sheriff’s Office has emphasized the complexity of the case.

This grim discovery has shocked the local community and left Overstreet’s loved ones seeking answers nearly two decades after her disappearance. While her identity has been confirmed, the circumstances surrounding her death remain unclear, leaving a haunting gap in the story of her life and death.

Next time somebody offers you a free freezer…maybe think twice about accepting it.