Student loan borrowers face significant payment increases as the Biden administration’s SAVE plan ends, forcing many to navigate a complex maze of alternative repayment options.
At a Glance
- The termination of the SAVE repayment plan means many federal student loan borrowers will see monthly payments increase significantly
- Alternative repayment plans like Income-Based Repayment and Pay As You Earn typically require higher monthly payments
- Borrowers who previously qualified for $0 payments under SAVE may now face hundreds in monthly obligations
- Republican proposals in the House Education Committee could further alter repayment options in the near future
- Financial experts recommend against refinancing federal loans with private lenders despite potential payment increases
Federal Student Loan Landscape Changes
Federal student loan borrowers who enjoyed reduced or zero-dollar monthly payments under the Biden administration’s SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) plan now face a harsh financial reality. The program, which provided substantial relief to millions of Americans struggling with education debt, has been discontinued. This discontinuation forces borrowers to transition to alternative payment plans that typically demand significantly higher monthly contributions, potentially straining already tight household budgets across the nation.
“The payment is likely going to go up for borrowers enrolled in SAVE,” warns Elaine Rubin, an expert on student loans.
Since March 2020, many borrowers enrolled in income-driven repayment plans qualified for $0 monthly payments. The SAVE plan would have extended this benefit to even more Americans struggling with student debt.
With the program’s termination, those financial protections vanish, leaving borrowers to sort through a complex array of remaining options, each with different eligibility requirements and payment structures that could dramatically impact their monthly expenses.
— Felipe Montealegre (IFS) (@TheiaResearch) January 7, 2025
Available Repayment Alternatives
Borrowers previously enrolled in the SAVE plan must now select from several other repayment options, including Income-Based Repayment (IBR), Pay As You Earn (PAYE), or Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR). Each of these plans calculates payments differently and has distinct eligibility criteria. For example, the IBR plan generally requires payments of 10-15% of discretionary income, while PAYE caps payments at 10% but has stricter eligibility requirements. ICR typically demands 20% of discretionary income or a fixed payment over 12 years.
“Each plan has its own eligibility rules and repayment formula,” explains Adam Minsky, a student loan attorney.
For those uncomfortable with income-driven options, traditional repayment plans remain available. The Standard Repayment Plan spreads payments evenly over ten years, while the Graduated Repayment Plan starts with lower payments that increase every two years. The Extended Repayment Plan stretches payments over 25 years, reducing monthly obligations but substantially increasing total interest paid over the life of the loan, potentially costing borrowers tens of thousands more in the long run.
Financial Impact on Borrowers
The financial consequences of transitioning from SAVE to alternative repayment plans are substantial. Analysis shows that a borrower with $30,000 in student loans at a 6.53% interest rate could see monthly payments increase dramatically. Under SAVE, qualifying low-income borrowers might have paid $0 monthly. Under IBR, that same borrower could face payments of $150-$225 per month. The Standard Repayment Plan would push payments even higher to approximately $341 monthly.
“Even if you’re comfortably making payments, if something were to happen, you might find yourself locked into a very challenging situation,” cautions Elaine Rubin.
The payment pause that provided relief during recent years is expected to continue at least through December 2023, with some experts suggesting it might extend as far as mid-2026. This offers borrowers some breathing room to adjust their financial planning. However, the inevitable resumption of payments looms large, especially as many Americans continue dealing with inflation’s impact on everyday expenses from groceries to housing.
Future Policy Considerations
Adding further complexity to the situation, Republican lawmakers in the House Education Committee have proposed significant changes to federal student loan repayment options. Their proposal would establish just two repayment paths: a Standard Repayment Plan and a Repayment Assistance Plan. This potential overhaul could bring additional changes for borrowers already struggling to navigate the current system, potentially introducing new qualification requirements and payment structures.
While some borrowers might consider refinancing their federal student loans with private lenders to secure lower interest rates, financial experts overwhelmingly advise against this approach. Refinancing with private lenders eliminates valuable federal protections, including income-driven repayment options, potential loan forgiveness programs, and hardship deferments. Once federal loans convert to private debt, these safety nets disappear permanently, leaving borrowers vulnerable during financial hardships.
Borrowers should prepare for these changes by using loan simulators provided by the Department of Education, consulting with financial advisors specializing in student debt, and reviewing their personal finances to identify areas where budgets can be adjusted to accommodate potentially higher monthly payments. Being proactive now may help avoid financial strain when payment requirements increase in the months ahead.
